VIshnu Sahasranamam: Sloka 1: Further Explanation

In the last post, we had seen the meaning of Sloka 2 of Vishnu Sahasranamam. We had also seen that Sloka 1 referred to "vighnam" and had noted:

"There is an interesting debate on whether the first sloka in Vishnusahasranamam is a prayer to Ganesha instead of Vishnu. So the question arises as to whether this Sloka is a later addition to negate the idea that the first sloka relates to Ganesha. More on this in the next post."

 In this post, we shall see what the debate is all about. 

Some argue (see, this for instance) that the first sloka of the Vishnu Sahasranamam (dhyanam sloka) is an obeisance to Ganesha and not Vishnu for the following reasons:

•  "Sarva vignopa shantaye" is a reference to Ganesha. "Sarva" means all. "Vigna" is obstacle or hindrance, and "upashantaye" means pacify or abate/ remove. Generally, Ganesha and not Vishnu is referred to as "Sarva vignopa shantaye".
• "Shashivarnam" literally refers to the colour of the moon. Vishnu is generally regarded as dark in colour and therefore reference to the colour of the moon can only mean reference to Ganesha and not Vishnu.

You would have noticed in the first post the difference between the poetic and the literal translation as regards the meaning of the words "Shashivarnam". The literal translation said it was the lustre (glow) of the moon and the poetic translation said it was the colour of the moon.

The authority on Shri Vaishnavism, Velukkudi Krishnan's view on the first sloka is given here: In one of his lecture series on Vishnu Sahasranama (in Tamil), he does not of course refer to the debate but starts off his explanation on the sloka with a statement that this sloka is a reference about Vishnu, probably indicating that he is aware of the debate. While explaining about "Shashivarnam" he admits that "Shashivarnam" literally means the colour of the moon, that is, white, but Vishnu is regarded as dark in colour. He explains this by arguing that it refers not to the colour but the nature of the moon. He says just as we see the moon, we get the feeling of coolness, likewise when we see Vishnu, we get the same feeling. This, according to him, is the reference to Shashivarnam in the sloka.

Some argue (here) that Ganesha draws his power from Vishnu. It appears that Brahma Samhita, Chapter 5, Verse 50 (here) says that Govinda has delegated his power of removing obstacles to Ganesha. Therefore, it is argued that the first sloka is not a reference to Ganesha but to Vishnu.

Conclusion

Irrespective of whether Sloka 1 refers to Ganesha or to Vishnu, the slokas pray for removal of all vignams (obstacles). It doesn't matter whether the "delegator" (Vishnu) or the "delegatee" (Ganesha) removes all obstacles, as long as these are removed, we are fine.